Boy, a Godzilla nes Creepypasta could have been just blood on the game cartridge and a giant Godzilla skeleton popping out of the closet. Instead there was a chilling atmosphere, horrifying images, nightmarish ideas, and haunting audio. Here is one thing that helped, this wasn't the usual Creepypasta in a five minute time restraint. This took time to develop atmosphere.
Personally my favorite character is Mr.Faucet by far.
AMAZING creepypasta btw, i enjoy the ones that have happy endings but still tend to be creepy after the ending (like selling the cartridge so we could possibly end up buying it and putting our lives in danger.)